Opinion: Incumbent leaders beware: voters have their eye on the escape hatch

Photo by Oleksandr Kurchev on Unsplash

By Mark Kenny

A version of this article was originally published by The Canberra Times.

Effectively, until last week, American voters were co-conspirators in their own democratic enfeeblement.

Historically, it felt irretrievable, not because of a single unfit president but because of the country's weak resistance, its apparent comfort with leaving democracy behind.

That equanimity persisted after Donald Trump's January 6 siege in 2021, enabling his reprise via a second-term landslide in 2024. And it appeared to survive a new war, his buddying up with dictators, unpopular data centres, his ICE deportations, and his boneheaded tariffs. Not to forget soliciting hundreds of millions in foreign gifts while attacking America's best friends.

Frustratingly, it was a period when Republicans, in thrall to an ego-driven dilettante, unburdened themselves from social, political and legal constraints. Science too was cut loose.

Self-describing "Reagan Republicans" cravenly assisted as executive power was expanded beyond congressional reach and the nation's highest office was monetised, privatised, and embarrassingly trivialised.

Equally frustrating was a new relativism of the public mind enabling almost daily assaults on decency and governing standards to accumulate - each new outrage helping to obscure the last - creating a glut of democratic abuses so commonplace as to become mere wallpaper.

Courts had been stacked and the Department of Justice, openly politicised. Enemies were prosecuted, the president's felonies ignored. Trump's delusional midnight utterances and memes depicted him as a healing Jesus. Meanwhile, his open threats of genocidal intent hardly troubled the headline writers.

A new "forever war" - something explicitly forsworn - kicked off with no plan, no end-point, and no recourse to Congress or the UN.

A vast paramilitary force, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, was charged with raiding farms, factories and families, arresting and deporting non-criminal Americans who had lived, worked and paid taxes in the country for decades. Communities were torn asunder. The innocent imprisoned. Those objecting were beaten, arrested, shot.

Violence was celebrated. America undertook extrajudicial killings and cross-border kidnappings. Trump encouraged supporters to kick and punch dissenters at his rallies, and hosted caged bloodsports on the White House lawns.

But then came the mid-term elections, where it turned out democracy still had a pulse.

Literally on the eve of the most pivotal polls since Watergate in the 1970s, Trump ran scared. At the Lincoln Reflecting Pool, site of Martin Luther King's nation-lifting "I have a dream" speech, he spent 40 minutes bumbling incoherently about algae, paint colours and the task of re-caulking the tiles.

One late-night comic dubbed it Trump's "I had it cleaned" speech containing "no symbolism, no metaphors, just straight-up pool maintenance". It was verbal diarrhoea. Peak puerile.

Then, the morning after the seismic result, the lame-duck president took reporters through the construction site of his vast new black-tie ballroom.

Back inside the White House, he signed yet more executive orders.

Was this a new urgency to deliver relief and hope to Americans impoverished by war and tariffs which together had sent gasoline, fertiliser and grocery prices soaring?

Hell no. These were orders to list his tastelessly gilded Oval Office and cabinet rooms as national monuments to prevent a future president undoing his life's work.

The idiosyncrasies of Trump's disintegrating presidency have exposed fatal shortcomings in America's system of government.

Presidential power has dramatically increased. Trump showed that congressional oversight is a paper tiger. And then there's the veto - Trump positioned a red MAGA-style cap featuring the word "VETO" on the Resolute Desk as he prioritised action to save his gold trimmings.

It is tempting to view the mid-terms as a high-minded repudiation of all of this - Trump's twisted priorities and his defiant cronyism.

At least one exit poll showed American democracy was near the top of voter concerns.

Sadly, for Anthony Albanese, however, two things were probably more pivotal - the rising cost of living, and, related to that, incumbency.

Recent results in Hungary, Serbia, Brazil and Israel suggest voters are stepping back from Trump-adjacent authoritarians in favour of responsive or centrist parties.

Opinion polls ahead of the national election in New Zealand this weekend appear to support this also, with the teal-like Opportunity Party (TOP) set to play a role - subject to clearing the 5 per cent threshold.

But it is equally possible that the real target of voter dissatisfaction, in a less party-rigid polity, is simply incumbency. In which case an age-old truth of politics might need re-learning: make voters worse off and they'll blame you. Around the world, voters are looking for the escape hatch.

Labor, seeking a third term, take note: high interest rates, high inflation, flat wages. Could a storm be more perfect?

Finally, some conclusions can be drawn from last week's earthquake. First, Trump promoted the combative ideologue, Stephen Miller yesterday, as his new chief of staff. It's a punchy move but also desperate. Pauline, take note. Trumpism may get louder but it is now dead.

Second, Trump's new priority is a 76-metre-tall United States Military Triumphal Arch, or what AP called "a mass of blindingly gold ornamentation and stately grey granite between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery". It will memorialise only his insecurity.

Third, the risk of Trump seeking a third term, as his Svengali, Steve Bannon, has long insisted, has been thoroughly extinguished.

Mark Kenny is the Director of the ANU Australian Studies Institute and host of the Democracy Sausage podcast.