Opinion: What is even the point of the Albanese government?

Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya on Unsplash

By Mark Kenny

A version of this article was originally published by The Canberra Times.

What is the point of the Albanese Labor government?

Too harsh? Probably. I once began a column about the Turnbull government in the same way, and he didn't much like it either.

But seriously, beyond replacing the duplicitous Morrison outfit (achieved in 2022) what do voters understand to be Labor's plan from here - its grand narrative?

More often, we get a kind of political-class patois such as becoming "Australia's natural party of government" - a spurious objective for a progressive reform party, especially one dominated for the first time in its history, by its Left faction. Besides, isn't that "natural party" malarky a goal for Labor rather than the country?

With the thick end of two terms under its belt, is it unreasonable to wonder why its reform story feels so, bitsy and terrestrial? And its lexicon, so cautious and repetitive.

Labor's spruikers will reel off a laundry list of legislative achievements and "saves", some of which were hard-won - on childcare, aged-care, gig-workers, social media, and now promisingly, on artificial intelligence. But others on the list are poor compromises like campaign finance rules, gambling advertising, the anti-corruption commission.

Even if, cumulatively, Labor's reforms amount to sector-by-sector transformation - and that is being generous - it would be a rare voter who could name its elements, much less feel inspired to try.

Meanwhile, insidiously "political" Morrison-era blights like the GST formula doctored to WA's advantage, and the Job-Ready Graduates outrage, remain unaltered.

Beloved, this government is not.

Rather it is in a deep hole, its hopes buoyed mainly by its 94-seat haul in 2025. Even this, though, is old thinking.

If the historic flip of red states to the Democrats in the US mid-terms conveyed a wider lesson, it was this: make your supporters feel poorer and they will dump you. Gains from the last election count for nothing in the next one.

It is telling that in every state that Trump won in 2024 by margins up to 10 per cent, his party was defeated.

Behold the new electoral reality as voter rigidities crumble. Take Farrer in May, where the Liberal Party vote in a seat it had held since Federation, dropped by an eye-watering 31 per cent. Or Labor-held Secret Harbour in WA, where, in an August byelection, its primary vote tanked by 23 per cent.

Both seats fell to the One Nation party - not so much for what it was as for what it wasn't.

Labor MPs resent the charge that the current federal government is uninspiring and reject as unfair comparisons with the "gold standard" Hawke-Keating period.

The argument goes that you only get to tear down tariff walls, deregulate banking and float the dollar once. Subsequent modernisations tend to be less headline-grabbing.

To be fair, this "was" true, (or true enough for politics, anyway) but given that everyone now agrees we live in tumultuous times, does it still fly?

Are not the challenges confronting us today more existential than the mere underperformance of an economy hampered by a fixed exchange rate, protected industries, and a leaden finance sector? Think raging wars, a disintegrating global order and the galloping unquantifiable threats of artificial intelligence. Or the cascading climate crisis. Add in the loss of faith in institutional machinery to solve these problems.

These are big perils to be sure, yet the most striking thing about our national politics, is the conspicuous absence of confident, inspiring leadership - on both sides.

This is not inevitable. In Canada, there is a sense from Mark Carney's program and his forthrightness, that these difficult times can support a typology of national leadership that is at once unifying as well as daring, imaginative, uplifting. Hungary, also.

In Australia, by contrast, even our policy successes, universal health insurance, universal superannuation, and now falling house prices, tend to be defended rather than expounded.

Further evidence emerged in recent days that Labor's curbs on property tax concessions are achieving what everyone claimed was desirable - a marked fall in the runaway growth of house prices based exclusively on future capital growth.

After decades of ill-conceived tax incentives, housing is being gently shifted from its use as a risk-free investment vehicle, towards its original, actual, purpose as a first-level human right in any civilised society.

The change is hardly painless, but withdrawing cashed-up investors from competitive auctions (for established dwellings) will come to be seen as an important step.

Even here, however, Labor's excessive caution saw any changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax ruled out before the last election. Their introduction since has thus become mired in controversy - less a symbol of principled reform than an albatross over a broken promise.

That said, there are good reasons to believe voters want decisions. Precisely the wrong response from Labor now would be to view its acute troubles as a reason to tread even more warily.

Rather, with companies openly profiteering from war, using AI to dump employees, and ignoring their social licence, governments need to act for voters, not markets.

Firms like Qantas were husbanded through COVID but are now callously sending Australian jobs overseas.

As breaches of faith go, it is hard to recall one more contemptuous.

This demands action, not words, from the federal government. More intervention, less introspection.

Mark Kenny is the Director of the ANU Australian Studies Institute and host of the Democracy Sausage podcast.