
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels
By Mark Kenny
A version of this article was originally published by The Canberra Times.
Survivors of cyclones and hurricanes talk of a surprising, almost preternatural calm in the eye of the storm.
Maybe we're there now, with things becoming wilder again this week as prices gallop and mortgage payments chase them to an 18-year high.
Economically speaking, getting to the other side of this tempest will be rough and prolonged. Politically however, the climate - as distinct from the weather - may be improving as exhausted voters assess the moral and institutional damage of the past decade and pause to count the thin achievements of indignant fringe politics around the world.
What they see is a whole lot of nothing.
Amid the institutional debris, the tattered playbook of populist nationalism has been blown open for all to see - a shouty one-page manual for acquiring unprecedented concentrations of power and wealth. To wit, ours. Whether it was clutched by Hungary's brutish authoritarian Viktor Orban to create his famed "illiberal democracy", Brazil's fast-scarpering nepo-baby strongman, Flavio Bolsonaro, or Serbia's Aleksandar Vucic, ordinary citizens are increasingly recognising that they'd been played. For all its gestural empathy, ultra-nationalism has left them worse off. Invariably, it sees public freedoms withdrawn and private oligarchs enriched, protected.
Populist windbags are still around of course, preaching their counterfeit oneness with the left-behind, and some may yet make electoral gains.
Looming state elections in Victoria later this month and in NSW in March 2027 could bring parliamentary progress to One Nation. Whether it proves durable, though, is another question.
In the "garden state", One Nation preferences seem certain to help end an unpopular Labor government and install a Liberal-National executive, probably as a majority operation. This is a marked turnaround for a shambolic show considered unelectable just 12 months ago. (At one point, it seemed that half the parliamentary Liberal team was caught up in legal actions against its leader or other figures)
For the usually dominant Victorian ALP, the damage will be done in three-cornered contests in regional and suburban Labor strongholds where One Nation could replace it through Liberal preferences - or vice versa. What will this mean for stability, especially if Liberal leader Jess Wilson does not secure a parliamentary majority on her own? Cue chaos.
In NSW, Premier Chris Minns explicitly wants voters to see One Nation as his chief competitor, telling Sydney radio midweek that its leader, Mike Newman, not the Liberals' Kellie Sloane, "...will either be the premier or the opposition leader after the 13th of March".
In politics, it always pays to consider motives. Even so, this was telling.
A canny reader of mainstream public sentiment, Minns sounded like he was dismissing Sloane while in fact he was inviting voters to think deeply about the dangerous radicalism of a One Nation state government. Goodbye sustainability, gun control, progressive social policy, basic respect.
Throughout the democratic world, the persuasive power of anger-driven populism might be waning. Some movements have plateaued; others such as Nigel Farage's Reform UK are now contracting.
Last week, the perennial war doctrine of Benjamin Netanyahu's hard-right government was rejected by Israelis. Where things end up remains unclear.
This week, Americans get their chance (again) to endorse or reject Trumpism with all its democratic assaults, abuses, miscalculations and excesses.
The mood suggests voters are tiring of tantrum politics and yearn for more than negative rhetoric.
Why? One suggestion is that by their nature, anti-party, anti-establishment insurgencies, are short-lived. Whipping voters up to a state of "peak-pissed" works only for so long before they take a breath and start asking for workable solutions.
Another suggestion is that the now global reality TV drama of the Trump White House, while compelling in its first few seasons, has jumped the shark.
Global ratings have dipped as viewers stopped believing the show's anti-elite proto-democratic tagline and focused more on the Succession-like avarice of its characters - how a dangerously unfit narcissist and his Addams Family cast of unqualified boosters, enriched themselves while flushing American prestige, global order and economic security down a gold-plated toilet.
We're still watching but would we vote for it? Reading the room, Barack Obama took the unusual step a few days ago in Ohio of openly mocking Trump's gaudy debasement of the White House.
"There's gold everywhere. What's up with the gold? He's got the White House looking like Saddam Hussein opened a Cheesecake Factory." It was right up there with Maureen Dowd's description of the Oval Office as resembling "a Vegas gift shop".
Republicans - mainly their tame media advocates if truth be told - rose in mock indignation, claiming Obama was being elitist in slurring a popular restaurant franchise.
Obama's boldness reflects a growing confidence across the centre-left that right-wing populism has peaked and that its global leader has become its chief liability.
Little wonder then, that voters in countries still lucky enough to retain the right, are thinking twice about electing Trump wannabes, foghorns, crooks, authoritarians and bigots.
What is undeniable is that people-power insurgencies which had appealed to gut-level sentiments with slogans like "take back control" and "make America great again" have led instead to deep divisions, illegal wars, deceitful governance and disastrous economic outcomes.
Mark Kenny is the Director of the ANU Australian Studies Institute and host of the Democracy Sausage podcast.